Kicking Up Dust on the Trail
The trail might be tough, but a cowboy always finds a way forward.
Christopher Houston “Kit” Carson (1809-1868) is often remembered as one of the quintessential figures of the American West. As a frontiersman, scout, and Indian agent, his legacy is deeply intertwined with the history of the Navajo, especially during the tumultuous period known as the Long Walk. This article explores Carson’s role as a leader during the Navajo Campaign, set against the backdrop of the Old Wests economic development from 1890 to 1912.
The Long Walk: A Dark Chapter
The Long Walk refers to the forced relocation of the Navajo people from their ancestral lands to the Bosque Redondo internment camp in New Mexico, which occurred between 1863 and 1868. Kit Carson played a critical role in this campaign, highlighting how military strategy and personal decisions intersected with the larger narrative of Western expansion.
Timeline of Key Events:
- 1861: Tensions rise between the U.S. government and the Navajo due to conflicts over land and resources.
- 1863: Carson is ordered to initiate a campaign against the Navajo, deploying tactics such as the burning of crops and villages to forcibly relocate them.
- 1864: The Long Walk begins, with approximately 8,000 Navajos marched over 300 miles to Bosque Redondo.
- 1868: The U.S. government signs the Treaty of Bosque Redondo, restoring some land to the Navajo.
Carson’s Military Tactics
Carson’s approach to leadership during the Navajo Campaign was marked by both effectiveness and controversy. By utilizing scorched-earth tactics, he aimed to cut off the resources that the Navajo relied upon, which ultimately coerced many into submission. For example, he ordered the systematic destruction of crops, livestock, and homes, which he believed would hasten their surrender. Although successful in the short term, these actions had lasting repercussions on the Navajo culture and population.
To the victor belong the spoils. – This adage reflects the mindset that influenced Carson and many military leaders of his time.
The Economic Context of the Period
Following the Indian Wars and the establishment of reservations, the late 19th and early 20th centuries saw a shift in the American economy marked by industrial growth and westward expansion. policy of assimilation pursued by the government was not merely about land control; it also had significant economic implications. By appropriating Native lands, settlers aimed to exploit natural resources, resulting in a new economic landscape.
An important aspect of this development was the integration of the Navajo into a new economic framework. The U.S. government promoted agriculture and livestock raising on reservations, hoping to transition the Navajo from hunters and gatherers into self-sustaining farmers. The introduction of sheep herding, for instance, became a cornerstone of Navajo economic life in this new context.
Challenges and Consequences of the Long Walk
The Long Walk was marked by hardships, leading to severe deprivation among the Navajo. Estimates suggest that nearly one-third of those who embarked on the journey did not survive due to disease, malnutrition, and exhaustion. experience profoundly affected the Navajo population, contributing to a spirit of resilience that would define their future.
This period also laid the groundwork for the eventual return to their ancestral lands and the establishment of a more robust Navajo Nation post-World War II, when issues of sovereignty and economic recovery became prominent.
Carson’s Legacy
While Kit Carson is often glorified as a hero of the American West, his involvement in the Long Walk raises challenging questions about the cost of expansion. Carson’s military success provided the U.S. government with a framework for dealing with Native resistance, but it also meant immense suffering for the Navajo people.
In the context of the end of the frontier during the 1890-1912 period, Carson’s actions and the fallout from the Long Walk highlight the complex interplay between military, economic, and social dynamics in shaping the future of the American West. myths surrounding figures like Carson often obscure these realities, reminding us to critically evaluate the narratives of American history.
Actionable Takeaways
- Understand the historical context of transitions in U.S. policies toward Native Americans to appreciate their long-term impacts.
- Recognize the importance of examining various perspectives in historical narratives, particularly those of marginalized groups.
- Explore the economic development initiatives on Native lands and how they have evolved over time.
“`
