Blog

The Colorado Plateau, stretching across parts of Utah, Arizona, Colorado, and New Mexico, was not just a breathtaking landscape but also a bustling hub of economic activity among Indigenous peoples before and during the Old West period. From the 1870s to the 1890s, this region was defined by trade networks that forged connections among various tribes. Unfortunately, these economic systems were increasingly disrupted by the conflicts known as the Range Wars. Understanding this intersection of commerce, conflict, and law provides crucial insights into Indigenous resilience and adaptability during a tumultuous era.

The Trade Circles of the Colorado Plateau

Before European settlers arrived, Indigenous tribes such as the Navajo, Hopi, Ute, and Zuni engaged in extensive trade networks, forming what can be described as trade circles. These interactions were characterized by the exchange of goods such as pottery, textiles, and food items, which were essential to their respective cultures. The trade routes were extensive, akin to arteries nourishing a body, facilitating not just economic activities but also cultural exchanges that strengthened community ties.

We were people who moved to the rhythms of the land and each other, our networks as vital as the rivers and canyons. – An elder of the Zuni Tribe

The Impact of Range Wars on Indigenous Economies

The Range Wars, primarily characterized by conflicts between cattle ranchers and sheep herders, intensified in the Colorado Plateau region during the late 19th century. As settlers pushed further into the area, Indigenous trade networks faced disruption due to expanding livestock operations, which usurped traditional grazing lands and water sources.

For example, in the late 1880s, a significant increase in sheep herding by European American settlers led to strife with the Navajo, who relied heavily on both sheep and trading. Cattle ranchers often viewed the survival of Indigenous tribes as an obstacle to their economic ambitions, leading to violent confrontations over resource allocation and land rights.

Law and Order in the Old West

The law enforcement landscape of the Old West was complex and often fraught with issues stemming from some settlers disregard for Indigenous rights. Many communities lacked formal law enforcement, and settlers often took the law into their own hands, leading to vigilante justice, particularly during Range Wars.

Justice often meant a gun in hand, not a gavel in court. – Historian of Old West law enforcement

The concept of law and order was often deployed selectively. Local governments, seeking to control burgeoning tensions, tended to favor settler interests over Indigenous rights. This bias was evidenced in land treaties that frequently pushed Indigenous peoples off their lands and silenced their voices in the legislative process.

The Resilience of Indigenous Economies

Despite the tumultuous period of the Range Wars, Indigenous tribes on the Colorado Plateau demonstrated remarkable resilience. They adapted by leveraging their extensive trade networks, preserving cultural practices, and engaging in negotiations for land and resources where possible. Some tribes began to assert their rights through legal frameworks, laying groundwork for future advocacy efforts.

Conclusion

The history of the Colorado Plateau during the Range Wars highlights a complex interplay between Indigenous economic practices and the socio-political upheavals introduced by settler expansion. Understanding this era is crucial not only for appreciating the plight of Indigenous peoples in the Old West but also for recognizing their enduring influence and resilience in contemporary times. trade circles that flourished despite challenges remind us of the fundamental human connections that persist even in the face of adversity.